…বাংলা
Barlekha Today logo
All the big stories — in your language, updated every 15 minutes
Home › Europe › News
Europe

European pesticide brands named in 1,605 Brazil poisoning reports, a third involving EU-banned chemicals

Staff Reporter
European pesticide brands named in 1,605 Brazil poisoning reports, a third involving EU-banned chemicals
Photo: Collected

Pesticides sold by European chemical companies were named in more than 1,600 poisoning reports in Brazil last year, an investigation has found.

The investigation by Unearthed and Public Eye was published on Tuesday. Analysing Brazilian health ministry data, it found that of 2,857 poisoning reports that named an identifiable agricultural product, 1,605 named brands sold by European pesticide companies.

About a third of the cases involved chemicals banned from use on farms in the EU because of the risks they pose to people and the environment. But European companies are not banned from manufacturing these chemicals, as long as they export them overseas to countries where they are legally allowed to be used.

According to the report, more than 6,700 medical reports involving agricultural pesticides were filed last year. Of those, 2,857 named an identifiable product; 1,420 were classified as confirmed poisonings and 1,108 as exposures, while the remainder were unknown or other diagnoses.

Under Brazilian law, healthcare professionals must submit reports to the national disease notification system in all suspected pesticide poisoning cases. Only the doctor or nurse who saw the patient can mark a report as confirmed poisoning or exposure only. Laboratory confirmation is rare, so a diagnosis usually depends on clinical judgment.

Vanda Garibotti, a public health biologist at the State Centre for Health Surveillance in Rio Grande do Sul, said insufficient training of healthcare professionals to recognise and manage these cases is a major limiting factor, and that high staff turnover and a lack of institutional support meant cases were rarely confirmed through laboratory tests. The investigation also noted that a brand being named in a report is not proof that it caused poisoning or death.

Farm workers in Brazil described their flesh rotting, skin burning, difficulty breathing and vomiting after using the chemicals at work, according to the report. A small number died accidentally or killed themselves by drinking the pesticides.

Among UK-made products, the most frequently cited was the weedkiller Reglone. It contains diquat, which was banned in the UK in 2020 after experts concluded it posed a high risk to people living near fields where it was sprayed. Despite the usage ban, Swiss-headquartered Syngenta still manufactures Reglone at its Huddersfield factory for export to countries with more permissive regulations, including Brazil.

Nelson Castoldi died last year after accidentally ingesting Reglone on his family farm in Rio Grande do Sul. To save money, his family had bought the weedkiller in bulk and decanted a single litre into an empty cola bottle; working under the scorching sun, he mistook the black chemical for a soft drink and took a sip. Though he spat it out immediately, the chemical caused his kidneys to fail before attacking his lungs, and he died two days later. His son Ivan Castoldi said: 'That poison, Reglone, should be banned in Brazil — not because of what happened to us, but because of its toxicity.'

The Brazilian health ministry recorded 75 cases involving diquat last year, compared with 36 over the five years from 2018 to 2022. Reglone was specifically named in 44 reports, including four deaths, of which 26 were classified as confirmed poisonings.

Dormex, manufactured in Germany by Alzchem and distributed in Brazil by the German chemical company BASF, is another product workers said injured them or made them ill. Sidnei Souza de Oliveira, 49, suffered a severe injury after a jug of Dormex spilled on his leg while he was filling a sprayer, when the handle broke. At first his leg turned red and he continued spraying; he carried on working for four days before going to hospital. He said: 'After 15 days, my leg was black. Chunks of flesh were falling off.' A doctor had to remove dead tissue. Dormex contains cyanamide, banned from use in the EU in 2008; the health ministry database recorded 17 confirmed poisonings involving Dormex last year.

BASF's Finale contains glufosinate, which was banned in the EU in 2018. Roundup, a glyphosate-based weedkiller manufactured by the German company Bayer, was frequently cited in Brazilian poisoning reports, including 12 deaths. Across all reports the investigation identified as involving products sold by European companies, there were 32 reported deaths; 31 were classified as confirmed poisonings and 26 were recorded as suicides.

Syngenta products were cited 425 times in the reports and BASF 179 times, though the figures are not mutually exclusive because some reports named products sold by more than one manufacturer.

Nina Schrank, a senior campaigner at Greenpeace UK, called the findings a 'deadly double standard'. She said: 'If a pesticide is too dangerous to use in Britain, it should be too dangerous to export. Ministers must stop allowing Britain to be part of a production line for toxic chemicals that are putting lives at risk overseas.'

A Syngenta spokesperson said almost half the Brazilian cases attributed to the company were not classified as confirmed poisonings and accused the investigation of disregarding the dataset's final classifications. The spokesperson added that Brazil has its own 'robust regulatory system', that products banned in Europe could still be independently assessed and legally registered there, and that the company trained 95,000 people in Brazil in the safe use of its products in 2025. Bayer said its products were safe when used according to label instructions, said it took pesticide poisoning seriously, but questioned the reliability of the data, arguing that products and circumstances of exposure had not been independently verified.

Get the news firstNew stories in your inbox — subscribe free.

More in Europe