…বাংলা
Barlekha Today logo
All the big stories — in your language, updated every 15 minutes
Home › Europe › News
Europe

Europe seeks China's support to break deadlock over IPCC climate reports

Staff Reporter

On the sidelines of the United Nations climate conference in Antalya, Turkey, European governments are counting on China this week. Senior officials from several European delegations are meeting their Chinese counterparts to win Beijing's support in a dispute over scientific reports by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, the IPCC, five negotiators told Politico.

Francesco Corvaro, Italy's special envoy for climate, described it as a major diplomatic initiative. He said, 'This is a major diplomatic initiative. We are working to apply pressure.'

The dispute concerns the IPCC, a body that publishes scientific assessments every five to seven years and whose views are treated as the definitive reference on the state of knowledge about global warming and how to combat it. The IPCC's scientists hope to publish their next series of reports in 2028.

The timetable is set by consensus among governments worldwide, but a small group of countries led by India and Saudi Arabia is seeking to postpone publication. They are also blocking the body's budget, plunging the IPCC into a funding crisis that could hamper its work.

European countries see China as the key to breaking the impasse. According to the diplomats interviewed, if they can rally Beijing to their cause, the obstructing countries may give way. Corvaro said China sits between the two sides and is not fully aligned with Saudi Arabia and India, so they hope common ground can be found with it to underline the importance of science and data.

The IPCC is due to publish three reports. The first will cover the scientific aspects of climate change, the second how to prepare for its effects, and the third how to prevent warming from worsening. The third is especially important for the second global stocktake, to be held at the next COP in 2028, where countries must assess their progress in implementing the Paris Agreement and take corrective measures, an exercise known as GST2.

A delay in publishing the reports would deprive climate negotiators of the latest scientific evidence. The European Union's chief negotiator, Diana Acconcia, told journalists last week that it is essential that the IPCC continue its work and that the seventh assessment report be delivered in time to inform GST2. She said, 'Europe sides with science.'

India and Saudi Arabia, by contrast, say more time is needed so that authors and governments in developing countries can review and approve the reports. An official from a developing country opposed to the 2028 deadline, speaking on condition that his country not be identified, said scientists in developing countries must be given enough time, and that this is a matter of principle, not an attempt to obstruct or delay the studies.

The countries backing the 2028 deadline, which include not only European governments but also many developing countries particularly vulnerable to climate change, disagree. Marshall Islands President Hilda Heine said last week that there have been attempts to discredit the IPCC and prevent publication of its reports, which will serve as the basis for the next global stocktake, and that Pacific scientists say the work can and must be completed on time. The leaders of Norway and Brazil also supported the IPCC's role in speeches in Antalya last week.

India and Saudi Arabia have proposed an alternative timetable that would present the first report, on the scientific aspects, in time for the interim stocktake, but would push the other two reports, focused on measures countries must take, back to 2029. France considers the Indian and Saudi position absolutely unacceptable because, in effect, it calls science into question; an adviser to minister Monique Barbut told the press he was very worried about the IPCC.

The timetable debate is compounded by concerns over the IPCC's funding, already strained by the withdrawal of the United States. Without a budget, the body cannot continue its work. For the sixth consecutive meeting, the IPCC assembly failed to reach agreement at a meeting held last month in Ethiopia. Countries are due to meet again on 1 December in a last-chance meeting to agree on a budget for the coming year. India and Saudi Arabia also have the support of Kenya and Russia, and according to diplomats China has also opposed an accelerated publication timetable, but they believe Beijing can be persuaded to change its mind.

With ministers from around the world gathered in Antalya, states hope the dispute can be resolved this week. One European diplomat, not authorised to speak officially, said there is an opportunity to reach consensus on the IPCC with the ministers present, and that if they succeed, next month's IPCC meeting should not fail; otherwise, it well could. A second European diplomat urged caution, saying they do not want to complicate the IPCC's task, but that if no budget is agreed in December it will delay and disrupt work on the next reports, which is unacceptable. The Indian and Saudi governments did not respond to Politico's questions.

A first draft of the COP's final decision, published on Monday, suggests countries are noting the importance of the IPCC for the global stocktake. The IPCC itself welcomed the discussions among governments in Antalya. Diana Ürge-Vorsatz, the IPCC's vice-chair, said the discussions among governments at the COP are extremely useful, and that it is crucial to take a decision very quickly because the situation is very difficult for the scientists involved and for the institution, and living with this uncertainty is very difficult for everyone.

Get the news firstNew stories in your inbox — subscribe free.

More in Europe