Rwanda hits back at criticism of EU return hub plan, interior minister says rights are respected
Rwanda's interior minister Vincent Biruta has rebuked criticism of a plan to set up a deportation hub for failed asylum-seekers in his country. Speaking on a panel at a conference in Vienna on Tuesday, he said human rights in Rwanda are respected and granted to everyone, and specifically to refugees who choose to come to the country.
Five European Union countries — Austria, Denmark, Germany, Greece and the Netherlands — announced a partnership with Rwanda on Monday. Under the plan, failed asylum-seekers would be sent to a return hub in Rwanda, with the first asylum-seekers aimed to be sent to the African country in 2027.
The plan comes after the EU adopted legislation that allows countries to negotiate deals to build such return hubs outside the bloc, as long as they meet human rights standards. The partnership with Rwanda was announced on that basis.
The announcement led to a storm of protest from civil society and human rights groups, which said the fundamental rights of people sent to Rwanda cannot be guaranteed. In a joint warning on Monday, 47 organizations pointed to a 2023 court decision that struck down the United Kingdom's plans to process asylum seekers' claims in Rwanda, citing substantial grounds to believe people sent there would face a real risk of ill-treatment through refoulement.
The joint warning added that, under a 2013 deal with Israel, people sent to Rwanda were routinely moved clandestinely to Uganda, as the court had noted.
Biruta said he was not surprised by the NGOs' warnings and said the government faced the same issue when it was making plans with the United Kingdom. Those plans did not work, he said, but helped to improve Rwanda's asylum system.
He argued that his country's migration policies are among the most progressive, as they allow refugees to work and start a business. NGOs always say that nothing is working and that the human rights record is bad, Biruta said, adding that he would like them to come forward with an alternative solution.
The Vienna conference was hosted by the International Centre for Migration Policy Development. EU ministers repeatedly stressed on Monday that their partnership with Rwanda would meet international and European standards. Biruta said his country would put in place an independent monitoring mechanism and wants to involve the International Organization for Migration and the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees.
Details of such mechanisms and cooperation, and how the EU countries and Rwanda will divide responsibilities for the refugees' wellbeing, have not yet been revealed. After the plan's announcement, Danish Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen said there are still technical matters to be solved, including where Europe's responsibility ends and where Rwanda's starts.
Human rights groups do not believe the countries can come up with a framework that will guarantee migrants' rights. Judith Sunderland, senior associate director in the refugee and migrant rights division of Human Rights Watch, said Rwanda has an abysmal human rights record, is responsible for serious abuses and war crimes in eastern Congo and engages in transnational repression. No amount of nominal safeguards, she said, will be sufficient to mitigate the risks of serious human rights violations.


