Blacklisted after its award notice, NDE's Tk 95 crore Rajshahi Medical University contract still not cancelled

Contractor National Development Engineers (NDE) Limited has been blacklisted for two years after receiving its Notification of Award (NoA). Even so, its NoA for construction work worth about Tk 95 crore at Rajshahi Medical University (RAMEBI) has not been cancelled.
Under guidance from the Bangladesh Public Procurement Authority (BPPA), if a firm is blacklisted while a tender is being evaluated, it is considered ineligible for the contract. Sources said uncertainty has arisen over the project work because the NoA has still not been cancelled.
Sources said the firm's office is in Banani in the capital. NDE won work under the RAMEBI establishment project to build a nine-storey non-clinical faculty building with a basement. The tender process was completed in November-December last year. The work period runs from 1 March this year to 1 March 2028.
Documents show 14 contracting firms took part for the work. NDE bid Tk 95 crore 40 lakh 2 thousand 379 and placed eighth. But in a re-evaluation of experience and other matters, the tender evaluation committee gave the work to NDE. The firm was recently given the NoA as well. NDE was blacklisted after that.
According to BPPA documents, NDE had won work to build a 12-storey building at Nikunja for the head office of Dhaka Electric Supply Company Limited (DESCO). The contract was signed on 3 June 2021. DESCO cancelled the contract on 12 May last year for not doing the work as agreed. The Ministry of Power, Energy and Mineral Resources and DESCO then barred the firm from 13 September this year to 12 September 2028.
In a circular signed on 15 November, BPPA chief executive officer Abu Sayeed Md Kamruzzaman said that even if a firm was not barred before a tender was invited, if a bidder is barred by any procuring authority during evaluation, that bidder will also be considered ineligible under the rules for ongoing or future tenders in process.
The circular further said that despite suitable provisions in the legal framework, some tender evaluation committees are deviating from the provisions and recommending barred bidders for contracts, and contracts are being made after those recommendations are approved. The BPPA called such activity a clear violation of government procurement law and rules.
Next after NDE in the re-evaluation is M Jamal and Company Limited. It bid Tk 97 crore 63 lakh 37 thousand 931 to build the building. The firm's contractor Mizanur Rahman said NDE has been blacklisted for two years. There are many examples of the second firm getting the work when the first firm is considered ineligible. But NDE's NoA has still not been cancelled, which he called disappointing.
Allegations have been received that a large sum of money changed hands to give the work to NDE. The allegations say the firm was given the work in the name of re-evaluation even though it was not the lowest bidder. It has also been alleged that its NoA is not being cancelled even after the blacklisting.
Asked about it, RAMEBI deputy director (planning and development) Engineer Ashraful Islam said NDE was blacklisted after the NoA was given. No construction work has started yet. A letter has been sent to the BPPA asking what should be done in this situation. Steps will be taken as directed, he said.
Vice-Chancellor and director of the RAMEBI establishment project Professor Dr Jawadul Haque said if the BPPA issues such a circular, everything is clear. In that case the work will not be done by that firm. Whether the next firm will get the work or a fresh tender must be invited will be learned, and then steps will be taken, he said.




