No re-tender on pay-order ground absent from tender terms, High Court orders Dhaka Zila Parishad to reconsider
The High Court has ordered the Dhaka Zila Parishad to reconsider a tender for leasing 70,000 square feet of land. The court asked the parishad to inform the petitioner of a reasoned decision within 30 days of receiving the certified copy of the verdict.
The High Court declared without lawful authority the decision to cancel the highest bidder's proposal and call a fresh tender on the ground that a pay order equal to the full tender price had not been submitted, even though the tender terms did not mention such a condition. It also ordered the Dhaka Zila Parishad to reconsider the tender following the published terms.
A High Court bench of Justice Md Toufiq Inam and Justice Mahmud Hasan delivered the verdict on November 12. The verdict was later published on the Supreme Court website.
In its observation, the court said an authority leasing government property must follow transparency, impartiality and a fair process. After a tender notice is published, no new financial condition that is not mentioned in it can be imposed on a bidder.
According to the writ petition, the Dhaka Zila Parishad invited a tender to lease 70,000 square feet of land at plot 641 in Mirpur mouza of Dhaka. Petitioner Asaduzzaman Asad took part and quoted Tk 26,60,000. He claimed that after the tender was opened on March 31, 2026, he was considered the highest bidder.
Later, on the authority's verbal instruction, he deposited Tk 3,99,000 as 15 percent VAT and Tk 2,66,000 as 10 percent income tax on the proposed price. In total, he paid Tk 6,65,000 in taxes.
While he was waiting for the formal lease letter, he was informed on May 4, 2026 that the Dhaka Zila Parishad's 16th general meeting held on April 7 had decided to call a fresh tender for the land. Asaduzzaman Asad filed a writ petition with the High Court challenging the validity of that decision.
The petitioner's lawyer, Md Jahangir Kabir, argued in court that a re-tender was decided without any legal reason even after the petitioner took part in the tender process and submitted the highest bid. The tender terms, he said, carried no obligation to submit a pay order equal to the full lease price.
On the other hand, Dhaka Zila Parishad lawyer Md Anwarul Islam told the court that the petitioner had not submitted a pay order equal to Tk 26,60,000 with the tender, so his tender was unacceptable. Paying VAT and income tax later, he argued, did not remove that basic defect of the tender.
After reviewing both sides' submissions and documents, the High Court said no clear obligation to submit a pay order equal to the full tender price was found in the tender notice or the related terms. Imposing such a condition later to declare the petitioner's tender ineligible was therefore not acceptable.
The court also said being the highest bidder does not automatically give anyone a right to lease government property. The competent authority has jurisdiction to accept or reject a tender, but that decision must be based on law, the published terms and fair principles. The VAT and income tax deposited by the petitioner must also be duly considered in reconsidering the tender.
The verdict declared the April 7 general meeting decision and the letter issued on May 4 to be without lawful authority and legally ineffective. However, the High Court did not directly order a lease or an offer letter in the petitioner's favour. It ordered a reasoned decision considering all relevant aspects of the tender, and said no new or unpublished condition can be imposed for that purpose.




