France Awaits Verdict in Michel Zecler Beating Trial as Prosecutors Seek Prison Terms for Three Officers
France is awaiting a verdict, six years on, in the trial over the beating of Black music producer Michel Zecler in Paris. On November 21, 2020, three police officers assaulted Zecler at his Parisian music studio. Surveillance camera footage shows the officers pushing Zecler inside his studio and beating him until other musicians intervened.
The three accused officers are Aurelien Lapersonne, Pierre Plantier and Philippe Tondeux. They are accused of striking the music producer 29 times in four minutes, and an additional six times in the face after Zecler was already handcuffed.
The three officers are also accused of forging a public document. All three signed a falsified police report stating that Zecler hit the police officers, a claim refuted by the surveillance footage. During the attack, the officers allegedly made multiple racist remarks towards Zecler.
The case fuelled wider concerns in France about police brutality and caught the public's attention. At the time, football star Kylian Mbappe shared an image of a heavily injured Zecler, blood running from his face, with the words: 'Unbearable video. Unacceptable violence'.
The prosecution's office requested a permanent ban on all three officers, along with prison sentences: six years without parole for Lapersonne, the officer who initiated the police identity check and submitted the falsified report, five years for Tondeux, the trio's leader and the most experienced officer present, and four years for Plantier.
A representative of the public prosecutor's office said in a statement that there is no room for a symbolic sentence, describing crimes, violence and racial slurs, a complete lack of control and an absolute determination to get away with it in the end.
In court, Lapersonne, who submitted the report, initially claimed that Zecler attacked the officers and struck out with his arms and legs. When the presiding judge asked if he had made that up, Lapersonne responded, 'Absolutely.' He told the judge he deliberately omitted the officers' blows from his initial report, out of fear, and that it was stupid of him.
Rim-Sarah Alouane, a legal scholar and associate researcher in public law at the University of Toulouse Capitole, said it is pretty obvious the case is about institutional racism, systemic discrimination and police violence, and that falsified reports raise questions about the integrity of the entire system. She said that without the footage, the case would not be here today.
A series of court cases has identified systemic discrimination among police in France. Last year, the European Court of Human Rights condemned France for racial profiling of Karim Touil, a young French national of North African origin stopped three times within 10 days in November and December 2011. In October 2023, France's high court acknowledged racial profiling during police identity checks. In 2021, the French government was condemned for gross negligence in an identity check of three high school students at Gare du Nord in Paris.
The trial comes as France's Senate considers a controversial bill that would presume police officers and gendarmes acted in self-defence when using firearms in the line of duty, placing the burden of proof on the complainant. Critics call the proposal a 'licence to kill'. The National Assembly approved the measure in July.
Alouane said that if this proposal were in place, Zecler's case would have been dismissed, calling the legislation very dangerous and saying it would strengthen a sense of impunity among police officers.
French police are also under scrutiny for their tactics during recent student protests, in which a 15-year-old lost a hand from a police stun grenade and another officer threw a tear gas canister at close range, shattering a 14-year-old's jaw and several teeth.




