…বাংলা
Barlekha Today logo
All the big stories — in your language, updated every 15 minutes
Home › World › News
World

Africa's own credit rating agency AfCRA makes the case for local data alongside global ratings

Staff Reporter

Reporting from Abuja says the African Union officially launched the Africa Credit Rating Agency (AfCRA) on October 7. African leaders first endorsed the initiative in 2017, and that decision has now taken shape.

Based in Port Louis, Mauritius, the agency is designed to provide independent assessments of African governments and corporate borrowers, drawing on local data and expertise to complement the ratings issued by international agencies. Its first sovereign ratings are expected by the end of March.

Its interim chief executive, Sifiso Falala, says AfCRA is already in discussions with 15 African governments, with research planned in countries including Mauritius, Kenya, Togo, the Seychelles and Burundi.

The case for AfCRA rests partly on the cost of how African economies are perceived by financial markets. A 2023 study by the United Nations Development Programme estimated that subjectivities in sovereign credit ratings cost African countries 74.5 billion dollars through excessive interest payments and foregone lending.

African governments have long argued that international rating methodologies do not adequately account for the continent's economic structures and circumstances.

The major international agencies — Moody's, S&P Global Ratings and Fitch Ratings — have disputed suggestions that their assessments systematically disadvantage African borrowers. At a Chatham House discussion in June, Moody's Marie Diron argued that analysis of four decades of global sovereign default data showed African countries with a particular rating had broadly the same probability of default as equally rated borrowers elsewhere. A sovereign with a B rating, she said, had an estimated one-year default probability of about 5 percent regardless of region.

Falala said a significant number of African countries carry speculative-grade ratings despite having no history of sovereign default. That, he said, raises legitimate questions about whether prevailing models adequately capture African economic realities.

Falala has made clear, however, that AfCRA's objective is not to manufacture better ratings for Africa, but to produce more accurate ratings in collaboration with established rating agencies. A stronger AfCRA, he believes, will contribute to a stronger credit rating industry overall.

Beyond sovereign ratings, AfCRA intends to assess companies, municipalities, banks and local-currency debt. This broader coverage could address information gaps about borrowers that receive limited attention from international agencies, while giving domestic investors additional assessments of credit risk.

Abdussalam Muazu, an associate chartered economist at the Institute of Chartered Economists of Nigeria, said limited information about African borrowers has contributed to the uncertainty investors factor into lending decisions. The big agencies have few analysts on the ground, he noted, and much of Africa's economy runs through informal trade, mobile money and community finance that is hard to measure from outside.

Financial market professional Dayo Obisan said African countries need rating methodologies that better reflect their economic circumstances and their access to capital. The value proposition of an Africa-focused rating agency, he said, centres on richer local data, contextual insight, wider coverage and support for domestic markets.

The agency describes itself as privately owned and self-funded, while its planned sovereign assessments will operate on a solicited basis — meaning governments pay for ratings and provide access to officials and financial information. The African Union says governments may not own shares in AfCRA.

Ultimately, AfCRA's credibility will not be determined by how many African countries it rates. It will depend on whether investors trust its analyses, whether its methodology withstands scrutiny and, above all, whether it can remain independent when its findings are politically inconvenient.

Get the news firstNew stories in your inbox — subscribe free.

More in World