Cautious Optimism in Europe That Trump Could Deliver Security for Ukraine

After months of anxiety, some of Kyiv's allies now think the United States will help deliver an acceptable peace for Ukraine. The unusual optimism among some in Europe has been triggered by a proposal from US President Donald Trump's negotiating team to give Ukraine a NATO-style collective defence guarantee.
European officials close to the peace negotiations are cautiously hopeful that the offer could signal a shift in America's position in Ukraine's favour, even though they remain wary that the price Trump will demand for such a sweeping commitment could be too high.
After two weeks of shuttle diplomacy, Trump's envoy and son-in-law Jared Kushner proposed the security guarantee at last week's press conference in Berlin, claiming the US president is open to such a 'big deal' and that the Russians are now comfortable with it too.
Neither is yet certain, and one Russian official dismissed the idea. But Russian President Vladimir Putin himself has not yet publicly rejected Kushner's plan, and European negotiators are taking it seriously, even if they want more information about how it would work.
A security guarantee for Ukraine based on NATO's Article 5 collective defence clause, which states that an attack on one member shall be treated as an attack on all, would change the game in deterring Russia from invading Ukraine again after this war ends. That is particularly true if America, with its mighty military, is bound into such a guarantee.
While few details are known about the proposal, if it were backed up by robust legal, military and political commitments, it would mean that a new attack on Ukraine would risk a direct conflict with the United States.
An aide in French President Emmanuel Macron's office said the US is heading in the 'right direction' but called on the White House to go a step further and give Ukraine full NATO membership. The aide, granted anonymity to speak candidly, said an Article 5 guarantee is obviously the best guarantee of solidarity among allies, and that giving Ukraine Article 5-type guarantees should not be overcomplicated: it means Ukraine is joining NATO, and the alliance's credibility rests above all on Article 5.
One reason some Europeans believe Kushner's offer is genuine is that he was not speaking off the cuff. In private, US officials have been floating the idea for months. There has even been discussion behind the scenes of the French proposal for full NATO membership.
Although Ukraine joining NATO is seen as a red-line issue Russia would never agree to, Kushner and his team clearly believe their efforts to discuss an Article 5-like option with the Russians have found support in Moscow. As a result, the mood in some parts of Europe has shifted.
One European official close to the negotiations said clear progress has been made on security guarantees, that on peace talks there is alignment with the US, no maximalist demands, and no discussion on European security without the Europeans.
The aim now is that more progress will be possible towards targeted ceasefires in the energy sector and the Black Sea the next time the US convenes peace talks between Russia and Ukraine.



