UK "complacent and underprepared" for a polycrisis of threats, Lords report warns

Ministers are complacent in the face of fast-changing and increasingly interconnected threats to the UK, and the country is underprepared for possibly very major crises, a parliamentary report has found. It calls for an urgent new approach to national resilience planning in the face of cyber-attacks, sabotage and the climate crisis.
The report was written by the Lords national resilience committee after months of expert hearings. It said that while Labour recently launched a "Be Ready" campaign advising households to stock food and water, most of the public are unaware of the scale of potential threats from cyber-attacks, proxy acts of violence or strikes on underseas cables, as well as natural disasters such as extreme weather and flooding.
The report calls for a new and coherent approach to resilience planning, including a dedicated cabinet minister for the task and an annual statement to parliament by the prime minister setting out the extent of preparedness.
Another recommendation is for the government to send every household a booklet setting out how people can prepare for and respond to an emergency, following the model of countries such as Denmark and Sweden.
The report also called for more flexible ways to communicate with the public, including a pause to plans to switch off the Freeview-style digital terrestrial TV signal, in case other systems are disrupted.
It said the UK's current plans were often out of date and over-atomised, dealing with responses to a single emergency such as a loss of power or water supplies or a cyber-attack, and not an increasingly plausible "polycrisis" of several disruptions blending into one another, especially as AI "supercharges" the risk from cyber-attacks. "The government must not treat emerging threats as distant or hypothetical problems. Doing so risks leaving the UK exposed as vulnerabilities develop," the committee warned.
Among the particular vulnerabilities highlighted are medicines and food, both dependent on highly centralised and generally international supply chains with few if any back-up options. The bulk of antibiotic medicines are now made in China or India, the report noted, with about 90 percent of the world's 6-APA, the compound that is the basis of penicillin-type antibiotics, coming from China. There is now only one integrated penicillin facility in Europe, and none in the UK.
With food, the committee was told that almost 95 percent of UK retail food is supplied by just nine companies from 131 distribution hubs, meaning disruption to just a handful of firms could create very significant disruption. On digital communications, it found that BT, which has a dominant role in the area, has access to just two cable repair ships — one French-owned and generally unavailable, and one UK-based but 35 years old.
The report said the Cabinet Office, which leads on resilience, should set out a national resilience strategy within six months, with proper funding and a more coherent assessment than the current national risk register, which lists 87 separate items. It also called for resilience to be embedded in civilian life, with a national register of volunteers and civil reservists, and the possibility of an entitlement to paid leave for people taking resilience-based training.
Jean Coussins, the cross-bench peer who chairs the committee, said ministers should not be "squeamish" about setting out the risks. "Evidence shows that the public would be reassured, not alarmed, by candid information. People are more than willing to step up in an emergency, but less clear as to why and how," she said.
A Cabinet Office spokesperson said the government would "carefully review" the specific recommendations, but was already working at speed — pointing to the national awareness campaign, the largest home defence exercise in recent history planned for next year, and investment of over £1 billion in pandemic security. The spokesperson added that there is still more work to do to make the UK as resilient as it can be, including working with and learning from allies.




