Russia's Different Strategy to Break NATO: Separate Deals With European Countries

In the northern Ukrainian city of Hlukhiv, a Russian drone struck a small house, trapping a nine-year-old child and her grandmother under the rubble. Two Ukrainian police officers reached the scene on Saturday to rescue them; after pulling the two out and setting off by car to take them to safety, a Russian drone struck their vehicle as well.
Police officer Mykola Savchenko was killed in the strike. According to Ukraine's Interior Ministry, during the drone attack the officer used his own body as a shield to protect the child.
The Russia-Ukraine war has now entered its fifth year. Russian strikes hitting the same target twice in succession have become an almost daily reality in Ukraine. Analysts say such attacks are also a symbol of Russia's recent activity: Moscow is now trying to target not only Ukraine, but also the Western military alliance NATO and Europe.
On the surface, Russia appears to be continuing talks through US mediation to end the war. Most recently, a Moscow-Kyiv-Washington trilateral meeting was held last week in Abu Dhabi in the United Arab Emirates, where Russian diplomats raised demands that would not be easy for Ukraine to accept.
Kyiv recently offered a ceasefire proposal, but Moscow has not yet agreed to it. The proposal called for fighting to stop along the current front line. There is a reason for Ukraine's offer: Kyiv does not currently have enough missile defence systems to shoot down Russia's missiles and jet-powered drones.
Analysts say Russia has now put forward demands that, if accepted, could collapse the post-Cold War European security order. According to secret documents seen by news outlets, Russia wants the NATO military alliance to withdraw troops from Central and Eastern Europe, and to promise not to enlarge the alliance any further.
Alongside that, Moscow wants to sign separate agreements with individual European countries – a different strategy. Under those agreements, neither side would carry out aggression against the other. Such a deal might look attractive to Russia's neighbours Estonia or Finland. After the Abu Dhabi talks, Russian negotiator Alexei Drobin said such agreements could also be made with NATO member states.
If such deals with NATO member states took effect, those countries might gain some additional security assurances from Moscow; but if one country after another signs such agreements, NATO's core principle itself could become ineffective. Under that principle, an attack on any one of the alliance's 32 member states is considered an attack on all of them.
Boris Bondarev, a former Russian Foreign Ministry official who quit in 2022 in protest at Russia's invasion of Ukraine, says that if such agreements are signed, 'NATO will collapse'; European countries would then have to face Russia separately, outside NATO.
Bondarev said that through such an agreement 'Europe will surrender to Russia without firing a shot. It will not have to lose a single soldier in its own defence, nor spend a single shell. It is absolutely clear that this kind of agreement is an attempt to break European unity. European unity is already under various strains. It is also an attempt to weaken NATO's unity.'
Russia's demands have been presented to US envoys Steve Witkoff and Jared Kushner, but not to European leaders. In Bondarev's view, the agreements could include conditions preventing a signatory country from joining another European country in a conflict against Russia, which would destroy the possibility of collective defence against Moscow.
Ukraine's President Volodymyr Zelenskyy finds Russia's demands unrealistic. In a post on the social media platform X last Wednesday, he wrote that Russian President Vladimir Putin 'lives in another reality'. A few hours later, at a press conference, Zelenskyy said no one really understands what Russia actually wants.
Davyd Arakhamia, a top Ukrainian negotiator who has taken part in every negotiation with Russia since 2022, also described how difficult the Abu Dhabi talks were. On Wednesday he said this round was one of the most complex, and that he felt the Russian representatives had come with very strict instructions, making progress genuinely difficult.
France's far-right leader Marine Le Pen has already said that if she wins next April's presidential election, she will stop France's military and financial aid to Ukraine within six months. In Germany, meanwhile, if the ruling coalition collapses amid debates over the budget, debt and economic stagnation, the far-right Alternative for Germany (AfD) could get a chance to win an early election; the party wants aid to Ukraine stopped, peace talks with Moscow started and sanctions on Russia lifted.
Kyiv-based analyst Oleksii Kushch said: 'If the European Union and the United States take the same position, it will not be possible for us to stand against it. The opportunity we still have to keep a balance between Washington and Brussels will also be lost.'


