Bush-appointed judge strikes down Trump administration rule limiting student visas

A federal judge appointed by former President George W. Bush has struck down a Trump administration immigration rule, ruling that the Department of Homeland Security overstepped its authority. District Judge F. Dennis Saylor IV of Massachusetts issued the ruling on Monday.
The rule would have placed greater restrictions on visas for international students, exchange visitors and foreign journalists. It had been drafted to plug an alleged gap in the visa system.
Under the rule, international students would only have been allowed to study in America for fixed timeframes, generally capped at four years, and would have had to apply for an extension if they wished to continue their studies. It would have replaced a longstanding policy.
Previously, there was no fixed time limit for international students so long as they remained enrolled in a university and otherwise maintained legal status.
The rule also would have imposed new restrictions on transferring schools, changing academic programs and pursuing additional degrees, while subjecting students to additional immigration reviews intended to combat fraud and national security threats.
The ruling represents a victory for the labor unions and university presidents that challenged the rule, and another loss in the Trump administration's legal efforts to crack down on immigration.
In his ruling, Saylor wrote that DHS acknowledges there are legitimate reasons why a student may pursue another academic degree at the same or lower level as one already completed, for example pursuing an M.B.A. after a J.D. But the final rule would effectively prohibit such a student from entering the United States to pursue those studies.
He wrote that the purported reasons given by DHS, protecting national security and preventing fraud, are not reasonably related to the nature and purpose of the F-1 visa program. "Put bluntly, DHS is seeking to prevent or discourage the very activity, providing educational opportunities for foreign students in the United States, that Congress sought to permit and encourage," Saylor continued.
Saylor had already blocked the rule from taking effect in September, but Monday's ruling went further by striking it down entirely after finding that DHS violated federal administrative law.
Lawyers representing the department disagreed with the judge's characterization, arguing that indefinite admission periods prevent immigration officials from periodically reassessing whether foreign nationals are complying with the conditions of their visas. Mandatory extensions, in the agency's telling, would create additional opportunities to identify fraud, security risks and immigration violations.
Saylor, however, argued that DHS failed to establish how an unreviewable, completely discretionary renewal system, imposed after a foreign student has already been in the country for four years, meaningfully enhances the ability to root out fraud, or how the benefits of such a system outweigh the immense costs of abandoning the existing system.
Currently, DHS relies on the Student and Exchange Visitor Information System (SEVIS) to monitor student visa fraud. SEVIS is a federal database that monitors international students and exchange visitors, tracking their enrollment, immigration status and compliance through information reported by schools and program sponsors. The agency argued that the system is a data-reporting system for schools and is not designed for performing all relevant fraud and security screening.
Saylor was identified as a Republican in a 2014 profile piece. The same piece noted his close ties to former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney and that he was reportedly considered for a position in the Bush administration. He was confirmed by a bipartisan vote in the Senate, winning the support of Democratic Sen. Ted Kennedy, who praised his fair-mindedness and independence.
DHS and the White House did not immediately respond to requests for comment when reached by Fox News Digital on Tuesday.




