…বাংলা
Barlekha Today logo
All the big stories — in your language, updated every 15 minutes
Home › America › News
America

Jennifer Sey sues Colorado over law she says could force her business to use chosen pronouns

Staff Reporter
Jennifer Sey sues Colorado over law she says could force her business to use chosen pronouns
Photo: Collected

Jennifer Sey, founder of the sports apparel company XX-XY Athletics, is suing her home state of Colorado over an anti-discrimination law she says could force her business to give up the language on which it was built. The company centres its message on protecting women's sports.

At issue is the Kelly Loving Act, HB 25-1312, passed in 2025. The law expanded Colorado's anti-discrimination protections to cover a person's chosen name and how that person chooses to be addressed. Sey and her lawyers argue that wording could require businesses to use pronouns and honorifics that conflict with their beliefs.

Hal Frampton, a lawyer for XX-XY Athletics, told OutKick that breaches of Colorado's anti-discrimination law can bring fines of up to $3,500 per violation. He said some advertising breaches can amount to a Class 2 misdemeanour punishable by up to 120 days in jail.

Colorado has taken no enforcement action against XX-XY Athletics since the law passed in 2025, and that point is central to the state's argument against giving the company legal protection while the case proceeds. Sey said she was not reassured, asking why the law exists if it is not to be used, and calling the state's position absurd.

After arguments on Monday before the 10th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, Sey's lawyers hope to secure protection before anyone files a complaint. Frampton, senior counsel with Alliance Defending Freedom, told OutKick that the Supreme Court has repeatedly made clear Americans do not have to wait to be prosecuted to challenge unconstitutional laws.

Sey is a former national gymnastics champion and a former Levi's executive. She launched the apparel company in 2024 with the stated mission of protecting women's sports. Its advertising and social media posts regularly challenge the participation of biological males in female athletic competitions.

Earlier this month, Sey helped lead a successful campaign for Proposition 134, which Colorado voters approved with roughly 52 percent support. The measure requires K-12 and collegiate sports teams to be designated male, female or coed, with eligibility generally determined by biological sex, and it takes effect on January 1. Sey said the campaign involved more than 3,000 grassroots volunteers and that the opposition spent nearly $4.5 million.

The lawsuit points to the company's practice of referring to transgender-identifying male athletes by their biological sex. One social media post cited in court concerned a male athlete competing in girls' high-school track in Pennsylvania and said that when boys run girls' track, they win and girls lose.

Sey's lawyers argue Colorado's expanded definition of gender expression could make such statements grounds for a discrimination complaint. Frampton said simply hoping no one ever files a complaint is not a good strategy. Sey said that if her company had to call biological males girls, the issue it was created to oppose would disappear.

In March, a federal judge denied XX-XY Athletics' request for a preliminary injunction, concluding the company had not shown a sufficiently credible threat of enforcement. The ruling did not decide whether Colorado's law violates the First Amendment; it meant the company had not established grounds for immediate protection while its lawsuit proceeds.

Colorado says the company is exaggerating the threat. At Monday's hearing, state lawyer Janna Fischer accused the plaintiffs of seeking broad preliminary relief that would let them misgender and deadname anyone with impunity, according to a Rocky Mountain Voice report by Shaina Cole. Fischer argued the 2025 law did not change any substantive rights under the Colorado Anti-Discrimination Act, and that the state's Civil Rights Division looks for a denial of service or conduct rising to harassment, rather than misgendering or deadnaming alone.

Sey said the dispute is not only about her and her business, but about all businesses and all individuals, and that if the law exists, everybody is afraid to speak the truth. Colorado's governor-elect, Phil Weiser, has also suggested Proposition 134 could face changes, because as a statute rather than a constitutional amendment it can be modified by state lawmakers. At a post-election news conference Weiser said anti-trans measures would need to be reviewed for necessary adjustments. Sey said she dared him to overturn the will of the people in his first month in office.

Get the news firstNew stories in your inbox — subscribe free.

More in America