Justice Department Issues Over 200 Subpoenas in Alaska 'Decoy Dan' Probe, Investigation Continues After Peltola Win

The United States Department of Justice has issued more than 200 subpoenas in its criminal investigation into Dan J. Sullivan, known as 'Decoy Dan', who ran in Alaska's Senate race. News of the scale of the investigation has come from a law enforcement source.
The disclosure came shortly after Democrat Mary Peltola was officially declared the winner. She was declared the winner of the four-way contest on Tuesday night, two weeks after Election Day. Peltola won 144,302 votes, while the incumbent Republican senator, Dan S. Sullivan, won 131,844. A Republican candidate, Gerald Heikes, won 6,105 votes, and 'Decoy Dan', running as a non-party candidate, won 4,760 votes.
The law enforcement source said the criminal case is continuing and that Peltola being named the winner changes nothing from an investigative standpoint. According to the source, the Justice Department investigation spans multiple states and there are multiple criminal targets in the case. A second source familiar with the investigation also confirmed that more than 200 subpoenas have been issued.
Allegations have circulated that a person with exactly the same name as the incumbent senator was found and put forward as a candidate in order to confuse voters and damage the Republicans' chances of re-election. The presence of two Sullivans with the same name sits at the centre of the controversy.
High-profile Democratic attorney Marc Elias is also among those who received a criminal target letter from the Justice Department in the case, reportedly earlier this month. Elias's law firm represents the Peltola campaign.
The controversy intensified only days before the midterm election on November 3, 2026, when a New York Times report said that aides to Peltola's campaign, the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee (DSCC) and political operatives outside Alaska had taken part in an effort called the 'ballot composition project', whose goal was to recruit a second Dan Sullivan into the race. Both Peltola's campaign and the DSCC have denied any wrongdoing.
'Decoy Dan' is a retired teacher from Petersburg, a tiny island town in southeastern Alaska. He had virtually no presence on the campaign trail, and even his neighbours reported never seeing any campaign materials from him. His campaign raised $35,556.
Peltola is a former state lawmaker. In 2022 she made history as the first Alaska Native elected to Congress. In 2024, however, she was unseated by Republican Representative Nick Begich.
Alaska election officials initially moved to remove the second Sullivan from the ballot, amid allegations that his candidacy was intended to confuse voters or siphon support from the senator. The candidate denied wrongdoing, and the Alaska Supreme Court ruled that he could remain on the ballot. The Justice Department also sued in October to mitigate the newcomer Sullivan's 'misleading' impact.
President Donald Trump had called on Peltola to drop out of the race and sharply criticised the Democratic Party over the alleged scheme. Speaking on 'Fox & Friends' on Election Day, he said the Democratic Party had looked all over Alaska for somebody named Sullivan, and, commenting on the lawyer Elias, said that in his opinion Elias should go to jail. Neither Peltola's campaign nor Sullivan's campaign responded to requests for comment on the matter, and neither did the DSCC. The White House pointed to the president's earlier comments on the case.




