House Democrats' bill would put a 10-year expiry on final removal orders in the US

Democrats in the US House of Representatives will introduce legislation on Thursday that would provide relief to some immigrants who have final orders of removal but no criminal record. The bill would also create a pathway for them to obtain lawful permanent residency, House Democrats told ABC News.
The move comes after President Donald Trump told CBS News' "60 Minutes" that he would "love to do something on immigration" with Democrats, who will take control of both houses of Congress in January after their wins in the midterm elections.
A final order of removal is issued by an immigration judge or immigration authorities and requires a noncitizen to leave the country or be deported. It becomes final once the person's administrative appeals are exhausted or the deadline to appeal has passed.
The bill, titled the "Protect Our Neighbors Act", was shared first with ABC News and will be introduced by California Democratic Representative Lateefah Simon.
Under the proposal, final orders of removal would expire 10 years after they were issued for individuals who have been continuously present in the US and have not been convicted of a crime. At present there is no expiration on final orders of removal.
Under the bill's text, an immigration judge could renew an expired final order if it was established by "clear and convincing evidence" that there was significant cause for the delay in executing the order unrelated to administrative or funding delays, and that renewal of the order is in the public interest based on new evidence.
While a final removal order gives Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) the legal authority to deport an individual, deportation does not happen instantly or automatically — removal can be delayed or suspended through the government deferring action, a stay of removal, ongoing litigation or other circumstances.
Former acting ICE Director Todd Lyons told lawmakers in February that about 1.6 million people in the US have final deportation orders.
The legislation would also create a pathway to lawful permanent residency for individuals with expired orders of removal. It is co-sponsored by California Democratic Representatives John Garamendi, Zoe Lofgren and Juan Vargas.
While Democrats are introducing the bill during the lame-duck session, it is unlikely to be taken up before the end of the year. But it could re-emerge on the agenda next year after Democrats take control and are empowered to send legislation to the floor for votes. Trump's openness to an immigration deal, however, does not guarantee he would back this measure.
The bill was inspired by the case of Harjit Kaur, a 73-year-old grandmother who had lived in the San Francisco Bay Area for three decades before she was deported to India. In September 2025, Kaur was unexpectedly detained during a routine check-in with ICE. Her attorney said then that she had been checking in with ICE regularly while under a final order of removal and had received authorisation to work legally in the US. ICE has said an immigration judge ordered her removed in 2005.
Kaur worked as a seamstress in Simon's district. In an interview with ABC News, the first-term congresswoman expressed optimism about bipartisan support for her bill and said she has spoken to Democratic leadership about it. Simon said that if deportation orders have been in place for over 10 years and a person continues to do everything right, those orders need to be turned off, and the person should be able to get in line with others for a green card.
Garamendi worked on Kaur's case when she was detained, and after she was deported to India he dedicated his guest seat to her at Trump's State of the Union address last February and left it empty in protest. He told ABC News that Trump had promised to go after the "worst of the worst" in his immigration policy, yet his administration has repeatedly and cruelly deported residents who had been working, paying taxes and raising families in their communities for decades.
The Department of Homeland Security and ICE have expanded enforcement in Trump's second administration against individuals with final orders of removal, including through deportations to third countries. Individuals who routinely appear for required immigration check-ins now face renewed risk of detention and deportation.
Kaur's family told ABC News in a statement that the pain they still feel remains, knowing Harjit is one of thousands who have experienced the same situation. They thanked the members of Congress for their continued advocacy and said they hope some good could come from Harjit's story through this bill and others.




