Charlie Kirk Case: Defense Seeks Pause on Bullet Fragment Testing

Attorneys for Tyler Robinson, accused of assassinating Charlie Kirk in the United States, are asking a Utah judge to put additional ballistics testing on pause as prosecutors attempt to conclusively link bullet fragments recovered at autopsy to the suspected murder weapon.
The Utah County Attorney's Office has asked the judge to deny the motion, countering that the testing it is seeking will not consume the evidence or prevent Robinson's experts from examining it once the government is done.
Deputy Utah County Attorney Ryan McBride, opposing the defense motion, alleged there is no reason to believe the bullet fragments contain exculpatory evidence, and that all the evidence points to the inculpatory value of the fragments.
McBride wrote that Robinson has allegedly admitted to the shooting. Three unspent cartridges in the rifle were consistent with the gunshot fired at Kirk.
The bullet fragments were consistent with the suspected murder weapon, although they have not been conclusively identified to it. Police also recovered video evidence and a Dremel tool consistent with etchings made on brass casings recovered in the rifle at the scene.
The fragment testing, known as virtual comparison microscopy or VCM, will not destroy the evidence, but according to court filings it is expected to physically alter or even damage it.
Prosecutors say petals from the fragments may be folded out of the way as investigators look for rifling markings on the underlying surface, fragments may be cleaned in a small area, and lead fragments may be cleaned or scraped. There is a risk that pieces break off during the process.
Robinson's lawyers want the VCM testing placed on hold until they have a chance to examine and photograph the same evidence, or an order allowing a defense expert to observe the testing in person or via video recording, something the FBI does not allow for reasons including contamination and national security.
They argued that prior ATF testing already damaged the evidence, and the next round of testing could result in further harm.
Jason Pack, a retired FBI supervisory agent following the case, said the ATF could not conclusively connect the bullet fragment to the recovered rifle, but could not rule out the rifle either — an important distinction that helps explain why prosecutors want the FBI to take another look.
Robinson is accused of shooting Kirk at Utah Valley University during a Turning Point USA public speaking event on 10 September 2025. During Kirk's autopsy, investigators recovered a bullet jacket fragment and four lead fragments from his body, according to prosecutors.
Robinson's lawyers wrote to the court that if the bullet fragment is again altered to the point where no independent comparison is possible, the prejudice to the defendant would be severe: the defense would be unable to independently verify conclusions, cross-examination would be unfairly limited, and the jury would hear unchallengeable expert testimony.
Bernard Zapor, a former ATF special agent in charge, said those concerns may be overblown. The fragments were documented meticulously during the ATF's initial examination, he said, with photographs, data and images available to the defense through discovery.
During prior testing, ATF examiner Samantha Karner cleaned the jacket fragment, photographed it and peeled the petals back to examine groove impressions. She identified the fragment as being in the .30 caliber class, but was unable to conclusively link it to the suspected murder weapon, Robinson's grandfather's .30-06 Mauser rifle.
Prosecutors wrote that the VCM analysis is non-destructive and uses 3D technology to capture multiple scans of the object, and that the scan data will be preserved and provided to the defense for its own analysis. To perform the scans, however, analysts may have to clean the fragments or fold back warped metal, called petals, to expose the surface.




