ICE to pay CSI Aviation another $305.7m without bidding, as deportation flights gain tracking secrecy

US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) has agreed to pay the private contractor CSI Aviation up to $305.7 million without competitive bidding, on top of existing larger contracts, federal contracting records show.
A contract change made in September added “LADD”, the name of a Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) programme that prevents planes from appearing on some public flight-tracking websites. The change may further inhibit monitoring of ICE flights, including flights to third countries, by immigrant and civil rights advocates.
On 31 October ICE also signed a new order with CSI worth up to $1.28 billion to keep running its charter flights for another year. Under the deal, CSI's staff will also draw up the lists of people put on its deportation and transfer flights.
Under ICE's own handbook and the original terms of the agreement, supplying those lists was the agency's job. The original terms, published by the Department of Homeland Security in 2025, said the government would give CSI a manifest containing the names of all passengers for each flight before departure. The 2023 edition of ICE's air operations handbook assigns the work of reviewing seat requests and preparing flight manifests to the agency's own air removal coordinators.
The staffing deal, posted to a federal procurement website in July, covers up to 140 dedicated flight coordinators at ICE field offices and air operations hubs, working 18 hours a day, seven days a week.
A justification signed on 16 July by ICE's head of contracting, Albert Dainton, says CSI is “the only source capable” of the work, citing its proprietary systems and integrated flight tracking and manifest management systems that work with ICE's operational platforms. The document says increased operational demands now require the services. With options, the deal runs to March 2029.
In a sworn declaration filed in January in the US court of federal claims, CSI's senior vice-president for government services, Richard DeLucia, said the company's personnel have full access to ICE's data systems to input data and verify manifests on every mission. He said 19 of CSI's more than 300 employees came from immigration agencies, mostly recent retirees from ICE and CBP.
Under the LADD programme, aircraft owners and operators can keep their planes off public flight-tracking websites, although the planes still broadcast their positions. FlightRadar24 reportedly received blocking notices for more than a dozen aircraft in March 2025, including planes often used for ICE deportations and transfers.
In May, 40 House Democrats wrote to the FAA saying ICE had misused the programme to shield deportation flights from public and congressional scrutiny, and that such use was outside the scope of the programme. Rob Menendez, a New Jersey Democratic congressman who signed the letter, said ICE operates in near-secrecy, evading congressional oversight and making it almost impossible for families, their lawyers and casework teams to locate their loved ones.
Angelina Godoy, director of the University of Washington's Center for Human Rights, said she was alarmed by the contract. She said there is no legitimate reason to remove such flights from tracking systems, and that secretly shuttling people across the globe with no effective oversight is an affront to democracy and the rule of law.
Fetaine Seddighzadeh of Human Rights First's ICE Flight Monitor said that since late September, all ICE Air aircraft that previously showed visible tails had become blocked on FlightAware and Flightradar24, and that as of 5 November the vast majority of ICE flights could no longer be followed by their callsigns either. The monitor now tracks more than 2,000 ICE flights a month, over 70 flights a day, and its work has increased threefold since last year.
Martin Strohmeier, a board member of the OpenSky Network, pointed out that LADD binds only commercial trackers that use FAA data; trackers relying on crowdsourced data, such as OpenSky or ADS-B Exchange, still show the aircraft. Seddighzadeh said, however, that tracking the flights that way had become an incredibly laborious process.
The $1.28 billion order was placed under a 2024 framework agreement that ICE awarded to CSI after receiving seven bids. The staffing deal was not competitive, according to procurement records, and neither, reportedly, was a $562 million order for flights that ICE placed with CSI in February 2025. A rival bidder, Classic Air Charter, challenged CSI's award at the US court of federal claims in February 2025. The Guardian contacted DHS, ICE and CSI Aviation for comment.




