Relying on AI to write essays can reduce brain activity and memory, MIT study finds
Relying on artificial intelligence (AI) while writing an essay can reduce a person's brain activity and memory. The finding comes from a study by the Media Lab at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) in the United States.
The study found that participants who wrote without any digital assistance showed higher neural activity in the brain than those who wrote with AI help. Their ability to remember their own writing was also better.
Researchers at the MIT Media Lab conducted the study to learn how using large language models, or LLMs, during writing affects the brain. A total of 54 students from universities in the Boston area took part.
The participants included students from MIT, Harvard University, Wellesley College, Tufts University and Northeastern University. They were divided into three groups.
One group used ChatGPT to write their essays, a second group used a conventional search engine, and a third group wrote with no digital tools at all. Each participant was asked to write an essay on a topic modelled on the SAT exam within 20 minutes.
The participants' brain activity was monitored while they wrote. The researchers measured brain activity using electroencephalography (EEG) technology. The essays were also analysed and the participants were interviewed.
The study found that those who wrote without digital assistance had the strongest neural connectivity in the brain. Search engine users showed a medium level of activity. Participants who used ChatGPT showed the lowest. In other words, as reliance on external help for writing increased, activity in the brain's networks decreased.
The researchers also tested the participants' memory. Immediately after writing, they were asked to quote sentences from their own essays. A significant share of the AI users had trouble remembering their own writing. In one session, 83.3 percent of the ChatGPT group could not quote their own essay correctly. By comparison, the search engine group and the group that used no digital assistance performed relatively better.
The researchers also said that many of the participants who relied more heavily on AI felt comparatively less ownership of the essays they had written.
For some participants, the study also included a fourth session, in which they were asked to switch from their previous writing method. The study has currently been published as a preprint and is still awaiting expert peer review.



