Decades of ignored warnings push US Social Security toward crisis, experts say

Experts are warning that the United States Social Security program is hurtling toward a crisis that could affect millions of people. A panel of top economists, including a Nobel Prize winner, warned Congress decades ago that its reforms could spell disaster, and experts now say that group was right.
Andrew Biggs, a senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute, said Social Security benefits were put on autopilot back in 1977. Since then, he said, Congress has done as little as it possibly could.
Senate Budget Committee Chair Ron Johnson, a Republican from Wisconsin, unveiled a report on the decades-old program that blasted it as a 'Ponzi scheme.' The report warned that Social Security's slide into insolvency began in the 1970s, when lawmakers opted to tie benefit growth to wages rather than inflation, despite warnings.
Johnson wrote in his report that an expert panel formed at the time warned lawmakers that if benefits were tied to inflation, Social Security would likely be sustainable today. Instead, lawmakers ran with their own amendments, which were signed into law by former President Jimmy Carter in December 1977.
Biggs said the warning in 1977 was that indexing benefit growth to wages would effectively build a solvency crisis into the program. It over-promises benefits the current system cannot afford to pay, and commits future taxpayers to tax rates that taxpayers in 1977 were not willing to pay.
In the decades since, Congress has done little to change the program. Romina Boccia, the Cato Institute's director of budget and entitlement policy, said that is largely because lawmakers have not had the political will to do it. She agreed with Johnson that Social Security was effectively a 'Ponzi scheme.'
Boccia said there is a misconception that many Americans think Social Security is a retirement savings program. For that, savings would actually need to occur in the system, and assets would need to be invested earning returns. That is not the case; it is a pay-as-you-go program.
One side effect of Congress's lack of action is that the wage growth formula relies on workers in the economy contributing from their paychecks. Boccia noted that over the decades, the number of workers compared with the number of retirees collecting benefits has severely declined as a result of a decline in fertility.
Biggs noted that Congress's last real successful effort to reform Social Security came in the early 1980s, when lawmakers were forced to step in to deal with a funding crisis. They raised taxes and increased the retirement age, fixing Social Security with months to spare — not because they wanted to, but because they were forced to.
Biggs said that in 2032 the same situation will arise, and Congress will be forced to take action sometime before the trust fund runs out, not because it wants to, but because it is forced to. If the trust fund runs dry by 2032, Americans' benefits would be slashed and paying for the shortfall would add trillions more to the nation's debt.
Johnson declared in his report that the Social Security problem could not be fixed between now and then because of Congress's inaction over the last several decades. He suggested the solution would be to repeal a possible benefits reduction as the trust fund heads toward insolvency in just under seven years.
Boccia disagreed with Johnson's solution and said the real answer was raising taxes — an approach lawmakers past and present would be hesitant to take. She said there is almost no way to imagine Congress would let those benefit cuts take effect, because it would be so politically toxic, so lawmakers will most likely try to find a different solution.
Boccia said the last time the trust fund was running out of money, in 1982, Congress put together a commission and voted on a bill that increased taxes and reduced benefits, including raising the retirement age. The problem, she said, is that the funding gap now is much larger — more than two times bigger than it was in the 1980s.
Biggs, who was part of former President George W. Bush's effort to reform Social Security more than two decades ago, said that had Congress taken action 25 years ago, Social Security could have been fixed in barely noticeable ways. He said there is no easy fix today, and that stems entirely from the fact that every year Congress had the opportunity to fix it, it chose to duck the issue for political reasons.




