California School Board Defies State Warning and Bans Trans Athletes from Girls’ Sports

A California school district has adopted a sweeping new policy barring biological males from girls’ sports, locker rooms and showers, setting up a potential legal showdown with state officials who had warned the district against approving the restrictions.
The Chino Valley Unified School District Board of Education voted 4-1 on Thursday to approve the policy, authored by outgoing board President Sonja Shaw. California Attorney General Rob Bonta’s office and the district’s teachers union opposed it.
Shaw said the vote marked a significant escalation in her efforts to protect female athletes, and she called on other school districts across the state to follow.
Shaw told OutKick on Friday that the board had passed a policy she authored that went beyond statements and resolutions. In her words, the board passed actual policy establishing clear protections for girls in sports, locker rooms, showers and overnight school travel.
She said these are common-sense measures: no boys competing in girls’ sports, no boys sharing girls’ locker rooms or showers, and no boys and girls sharing hotel rooms on school trips, protecting girls’ privacy and safety.
Shaw claimed Chino Valley Unified is the first California school district to formally adopt such restrictions in board policy, following a resolution she authored in 2025 that was subsequently adopted by other districts.
The policy, titled “Fairness in Girls’ Athletics and Privacy in Sex-Based Facilities,” establishes eligibility for girls’ athletic teams based on biological sex at birth rather than gender identity.
Under the accompanying administrative regulations, eligibility will generally be determined using existing student enrollment records reflecting sex at or near birth. When those records are unavailable or have been amended, the district may require a birth certificate issued around the time of birth or a statement from a licensed healthcare provider based on a routine athletic physical.
The regulations also explicitly prohibit requiring students to undergo additional examinations, tests or inspections beyond the standard physical required of all athletes.
The vote came one day after Bonta’s office sent the district a letter warning that the proposed restrictions conflicted with California law. Deputy Attorney General Edward Nugent urged the district to reject the proposal, or at least delay the vote.
The law, enacted through Assembly Bill 1266 in 2013, has been a central point of conflict between California officials and the Trump administration over transgender participation in girls’ sports. Shaw rejected the state’s warning and publicly challenged Bonta, arguing that federal law takes precedence over conflicting state requirements.
The district’s policy specifically invokes the US Supreme Court’s June 30 decision in West Virginia v. B.P.J. and Little v. Hecox, which upheld laws in West Virginia and Idaho restricting participation in female sports to biological females. However, that ruling only protects state laws that currently exist; in California, state law continues to allow transgender students to compete according to their gender identity.
In August, a federal district court dismissed the Trump administration’s lawsuit against the California Department of Education and CIF over the state’s transgender athlete policies. The court did not resolve the broader question of whether transgender participation in girls’ sports violates Title IX, instead finding insufficient legal notice to justify imposing the federal government’s interpretation as a condition of funding.
The Chino Valley policy directs the superintendent to consult legal counsel and take lawful steps to protect students and federal funding if state requirements are applied in a manner that conflicts with the district’s new restrictions.
The vote came during Shaw’s final meeting on the Chino Valley school board, after she unsuccessfully ran for California superintendent of public instruction earlier this month. Shaw said that despite leaving the board, she would continue advocating for sex-based eligibility requirements in girls’ sports statewide.




