…বাংলা
Barlekha Today logo
All the big stories — in your language, updated every 15 minutes
Home › Economy & Business › News
Economy & Business

VAT Burden on the Poor Seven Times Higher Than on the Rich: RAPID Study

Staff Reporter

The burden of indirect tax, or VAT, on lower-income people in the country's existing tax structure is seven times higher than on the wealthy, a study has found. The finding comes from research conducted by the private research organisation Research and Policy Integration for Development (RAPID).

According to the study, the poorest 10 percent of households have to provide 20.37 percent of their income as VAT to the government exchequer. For the richest 10 percent of households, the rate is only 2.80 percent of income. As a proportion of income, the poor therefore bear a much heavier VAT burden.

The study, titled Missing Revenue in Bangladesh: Tax Potential, Gaps and Distributional Consequences, was conducted with support from Friedrich Ebert Stiftung (FES) Bangladesh and led by RAPID Chairman M A Razzaq.

A discussion and publication event was organised at a local hotel on Saturday to release the findings. Finance Secretary Md Khairuzzaman Majumder, NBR Member Syed Mushfiqur Rahman, PRI Chairman Zaidi Sattar, Dhaka University Professor Sayema Haque Bidisha and ERF President Daulat Akhtar were present.

The study found the VAT pressure is even clearer between rural and urban areas. Extremely poor rural households pay more than 23 percent of their income as VAT, while poor urban households pay 16.5 percent.

On the other hand, the poorest 70 percent of households have virtually no personal income tax, as they are below the taxable income threshold. In contrast, the richest 10 percent of households pay 11.03 percent of their income as personal income tax.

The study also noted that the highest-earning 10 percent of households hold more than 40 percent of total household income, and under prevailing tax rates this group is supposed to pay more than 93 percent of potential personal income tax.

However, a large gap remains in direct tax collection. Only 3.57 percent of the country's total labour force is registered as active income taxpayers. Among TIN holders, the return filing rate is 43.1 percent for individuals and other categories, and only 23.6 percent for companies.

Alongside income, wealth inequality in the country is also stark, the study found. The wealthiest 1 percent of households hold 47.4 percent of the country's total real personal wealth, and the top 10 percent control 76.4 percent. In contrast, the half of households with the least wealth own only 3.4 percent.

Analysing 2021-22 fiscal year statistics, the study showed uncollected personal income tax and domestic VAT that year amounted to 5.89 percent of GDP. Potential personal income tax was supposed to be 4.85 percent of GDP, but only 0.98 percent was collected. Similarly, domestic VAT collection potential was 3.82 percent, while actual collection was 1.80 percent.

RAPID observed that the government is losing huge revenue because of gaps in business registration, concealment of sales information and failure to deposit collected VAT into the government exchequer.

RAPID estimated that without imposing any new tax or raising rates, the tax-GDP ratio could be raised from 7.3 percent to about 13.5 percent simply through proper enforcement of existing laws, widening the tax net and preventing evasion.

To achieve that, researchers proposed expanding the income tax base with emphasis on the wealthy, improving the VAT collection system, reviewing corporate tax exemptions and considering an inheritance tax. They also stressed modernising tax administration, eliminating harassment and corruption, and improving the quality of public spending.

RAPID Chairman M A Razzaq said success in revenue collection cannot be judged only by how much money is collected. How fair and transparent the tax system is, how free taxpayers are from harassment, and how much quality public service people receive in return for taxes are equally important.

Get the news firstNew stories in your inbox — subscribe free.

More in Economy & Business