Bangladesh-India ties held hostage by Hasina's presence, India also to blame: Kugelman
US South Asia analyst Michael Kugelman has said Bangladesh-India relations have in a sense been held hostage by Sheikh Hasina's presence in India. But he believes not only Sheikh Hasina, the Indian government must also take responsibility for this situation.
Kugelman made the remarks in an interview with the English-language outlet Daily Wada on Saturday (21 November).
He said India has signalled interest in working with the government of Bangladesh Prime Minister Tarique Rahman. But Sheikh Hasina's stay in India has created complications for Bangladesh in the bilateral relationship, making close work with India politically sensitive in Bangladesh's domestic politics.
Kugelman believes that, in normalising and making Bangladesh-India relations effective, the harder decisions will have to be taken more by Bangladesh, not India.
Earlier, former US ambassador Dan Mozena had told the same outlet that Sheikh Hasina should not be allowed to hold Bangladesh's India policy hostage. Kugelman said he partly agrees with Mozena, adding that while relations have in a sense been held hostage by Hasina, the Indian government also bears significant responsibility.
In his view, New Delhi could have allowed Sheikh Hasina to stay in India while imposing restrictions on her political activities, especially on making public political statements.
The analyst also spoke about India's long-standing influence in Bangladesh's domestic politics. He said there has been a perception in Bangladesh for many years that India interferes in the country's internal affairs, which is unhealthy and in some cases inappropriate. But he noted the BNP wants a constructive relationship with India, whose basis must be mutual equality and respect. If Bangladesh is treated as a junior partner, the desired relationship will not develop.
The interview also raised India's criticism over the situation of the Hindu community in Bangladesh. Kugelman said India's allegations about the situation in Bangladesh are exaggerated, and the treatment of Muslims in India also needs to be considered. To reduce tensions, New Delhi should tone down such allegations or refrain from raising them publicly.
Kugelman also assessed the prospect of Sheikh Hasina returning home. He believes that despite repeated promises to return, in reality there is no prospect of her return. He also warned that next year, economic crisis, energy sector pressure and the 'Hasina factor' together could make Bangladesh one of South Asia's most unstable states.
The US analyst viewed Bangladesh's recent election positively. In his view, the February election was the first free and fair election held in the country in several years. He also expressed hope that Bangladesh's stability would hold regardless of which party is in power.


