A Promised Loan Became a Trap: California Ticket Seller Vahe Shahinian Has Fought for Seven Years

Vahe Shahinian lives in Glendale, California. Sitting at a desk tucked into a corner of his teenage bedroom, a place he never intended to return to well into middle age, he rereads the emails that split his life into before and after. He alleges that a lending deal was fraud, and he has waged a seven-year battle to recoup multimillion-dollar debts from it.
It began in 2019, when a broker offered to fund Shahinian’s small business with a line of credit worth $750,000. At the time his company sold tickets and produced concerts around Los Angeles and beyond, like a miniature Live Nation-Ticketmaster, and he imagined what stable funding would let him do.
The pitch had a catch: Shahinian would first accept a third of the sum and start paying it back immediately, in daily installments of $3,600. After 30 days, he could access the rest of the money. He crunched the numbers, followed up with questions, and took the deal.
Shahinian says he sent the daily payments for 30 days, then 40, then 50. The line of credit never materialized. In his words, from that day it has been one long nightmare.
Shahinian had been in business for 15 years. Educated as a computer scientist, he had spent years programming satellites as an aerospace engineer. In 2004 he developed a platform for ticketing and seating charts called It’s My Seat. He grew the business from selling tickets to local events to producing his own shows: his first concert, by a flamenco guitarist, sold 400 seats; the next, 700. Three years later, singer Engelbert Humperdinck performed for 3,000. In 2015, Shahinian expanded again into touring.
By 2018, Shahinian says, his ticket sales were climbing toward $5 million a year and his profits were $250,000. He says he had never missed a payment in his life, and American Express had repeatedly approved him for short-term merchant financing at a low interest rate of 6 percent.
But before his biggest tour yet, with a 1980s German superstar, Amex told him it was phasing out the program. Tours are costly, with down payments for venues, marketing, airfare, lights and sound, and he had left himself about two weeks to acquire roughly $200,000.
Small businesses in the United States often turn to merchant cash advances, known as MCAs, because they find few alternatives, especially in an emergency. Traditional lending takes months and vigorous vetting. According to the Treasury Department, big banks reject about 20 percent of business loan applications and respond to a quarter with only partial funding. MCAs, by contrast, offer large sums within hours.
Their fees, however, run from 25 percent to 200 percent and more when translated into an annual rate. MCA firms argue they charge a lot because they take on big risks. MCAs escape most lending laws because, technically, they are not loans: an MCA is a purchase of future sales. Funders generally are not required to be licensed and face no legal limit on charges. Most collect payment by withdrawing directly from borrowers’ bank accounts, often daily.
Shahinian says that after the Amex rejection he lined up two cash advances totaling $250,000, owing back almost $400,000. The advances saved his concert tour but cost him all the profits. Even then, MCA pitches never stopped, and he repeatedly replied that he wanted only a traditional loan, something around an 8 percent interest rate.
Then came the offer that changed his life: a line of credit of up to $750,000 at an annual interest rate of just under 9 percent. Shahinian thought someone had finally recognized the quality of his business. He did not recognize the condition, 30 days of daily $3,600 payments, as a merchant cash advance. He says the broker presented it on the phone as a routine test of his dependability before he would qualify for the preapproved line of credit. He had no lawyer or adviser then. The finance firm was Wall Street-based EIN Cap, which advertised itself as a provider of working capital to local businesses.
From the start, Shahinian says, he received $228,000 instead of the promised $250,000; the difference was withheld as an initial fee, a common feature of MCAs. He set aside almost half the funds to cover his daily $3,600 payments, and the rest went into venue down payments and other tour investments. After 30 days, when the line of credit did not materialize, the broker portrayed the delays as technical. Shahinian’s emails grew urgent: he wrote that he had calculated and planned everything based on the 30-day plan and that he was basically out of time.
EIN Cap later argued in court that it never promised Shahinian any loans or lines of credit, only a merchant cash advance, which it delivered. The company said it was the brokers, the middlemen, who arranged the deal and made the promises. Much of what the company had to say about its ties to those brokers is in sealed depositions.
After 40 days of daily payments, Shahinian says, his bank account hit zero for the first time. His lawyer, Shane Heskin, who has been clashing with MCA companies for a decade, calls what happened “carroting”: dangling an attractive low-interest loan like a carrot to get a small-business owner to sign an unsolicited MCA. Heskin says he sees two or three such cases a week and that they are exploding; common targets are first-time business owners, first-time borrowers and especially immigrants.
NPR spoke with several other entrepreneurs who said they were carroted in similar ways. One described falling into a deep depression; another declared bankruptcy. None except Shahinian wanted to speak on the record. Shahinian says he paid his unwanted MCA to the end, hemorrhaging cash. His lawsuit against his funders could become one of the first of its kind to go to trial, though the trial date was recently delayed for the third time.




