…বাংলা
Barlekha Today logo
All the big stories — in your language, updated every 15 minutes
Home › Law & Crime › News
Law & Crime

Non-Party Cannot File Contempt Case Claiming Benefit of Another's Judgment: High Court

Staff Reporter

The High Court has dismissed a contempt of court case filed over the alleged failure to absorb and appoint a former Forest Department project employee into the revenue sector. The court also relieved the officials concerned of the contempt allegation.

In its judgment, the court said a person of a similar category who was not a party to a case cannot in every case claim the benefit of that case's judgment. In particular, if a judgment applies only to the parties to that case, no one else can file a contempt case demanding its implementation.

A bench of Justice J B M Hassan and Justice Aziz Ahmed Bhuiyan delivered the judgment on Sunday, 22 November, disposing of a contempt rule issued in 2025.

Barrister Mohammad Humayun Kabir Pallab appeared for the respondents, assisted by Barrister Md Kawsar and Md Suman Rahat.

According to the case details, applicant Md Jahangir Alam joined the Forest Department's Sundarbans Biodiversity Conservation Project as an Assistant Conservator of Forests in 2001. The project ended in 2005.

Later, nine employees of that project filed a writ petition with the High Court in 2013 seeking directions for their absorption into the revenue sector. In 2014 the High Court ordered their absorption, and the Appellate Division later upheld that judgment. The authorities concerned then appointed the nine to the revenue sector.

Jahangir Alam, although not a party to that writ case, applied in February 2025 for his own absorption as an Assistant Conservator of Forests under the same judgment. The authorities said they were unable to appoint him under that judgment after considering existing laws and rules.

He then filed a contempt case against the Secretary of the Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change, the Secretary of the Ministry of Public Administration, the Chief Conservator of Forests and a Conservator of Forests.

The High Court had issued a contempt rule in light of a decision of the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court in another case. After the final hearing, however, the court discharged the rule.

The court made several important observations. It said that for implementing a judgment in rem or a judgment or order concerning a policy decision of the government, a person of a similar category may file a contempt case even without being a party. But if a judgment is a judgment in personam, applying only to its parties, no one else, even in a similar position, can file a contempt case demanding its implementation.

The court also said a person who remained inactive or waited for a long time to take the benefit of a judgment given for plaintiffs in a case cannot later file a contempt case. Delay in filing and lack of transparency in the application can be obstacles to getting just relief.

The judgment also said that if the subject of a contempt allegation needs to be settled through a proper judicial process, that relief cannot be obtained through such a case. A contempt case offers no scope to grant any fundamental relief beyond the main allegation.

The court said that to convict someone of contempt, violation of a specific judgment or order of the court must be proved beyond doubt.

The court considered that creating scope through a contempt case to grant fresh fundamental relief would open the way for countless new claims in the judicial process, which is not desirable.

Lawyers say the judgment will be considered an important guideline on the jurisdiction to file contempt cases, the right to enjoy the benefit of a judgment and determining liability for disobeying a court order. In particular, the High Court's observation on when non-parties can claim the benefit of another's judgment may play a significant role in future judicial proceedings.

Get the news firstNew stories in your inbox — subscribe free.

More in Law & Crime