…বাংলা
Barlekha Today logo
All the big stories — in your language, updated every 15 minutes
Home › America › News
America

All charges dropped against driver in Florida grandmother's parking-lot death, family outraged

Staff Reporter
All charges dropped against driver in Florida grandmother's parking-lot death, family outraged
Photo: Collected

The criminal case against the driver accused of backing over and killing 82-year-old Deborah Murphy in a grocery store parking lot in Florida has been dismissed. Larry Basford, state attorney for Florida's Fourteenth Judicial Circuit, told Fox News Digital the man will not face any charges for the accident, saying several factors prevented prosecutors from pursuing and securing charges under Florida law.

Basford said everyone would agree what the driver did was careless and negligent, but that not every tragedy amounts to a crime. Murphy's daughter Amy Edge said the news was heartbreaking for the family; she and her twin sister Beth Schulz told Fox News Digital that both sets of tires crushed their mother's body before the car stopped.

According to court records, on 17 May Murphy walked back to her car carrying a bag after a brief stop at the Publix store in Panama City Beach. Surveillance video shows her striding through the crosswalk toward her car when she was struck by a Toyota 4Runner moving in reverse; she was facing away from the vehicle as she walked and apparently did not see it coming, the video shows.

The driver, Carlos Suarez-Contreras, was a 26-year-old from Venezuela who was in the United States illegally, arrest records show. He was driving with a canceled Georgia license. Murphy was pushed to the ground by the SUV, but it did not stop; according to an arrest affidavit submitted by the Florida Highway Patrol, the car continued backing up, running over her.

Suarez-Contreras had been charged with driving with a canceled license and causing a death, a third-degree felony. He was held without bond because of his immigration status and because he was thought to be a potential flight risk, Florida Highway Patrol records show. Murphy was taken to hospital and died from blunt force injuries less than an hour later, her daughters said.

Basford said prosecutors worked on the case for almost six months, searching for answers that could lead to a conviction and trying not to leave any stone unturned. They found that Suarez-Contreras's driver's license had been canceled, but it became invalid only a day before the accident. The Georgia Department of Driver Services confirmed to Fox News Digital that his license had been canceled; citing privacy concerns, an agency spokeswoman would not say when it had been canceled or when he would have been notified.

Basford said that under Florida law prosecutors have to prove the individual knew his license was suspended, and that question of knowledge proved problematic. Prosecutors considered charging him with vehicular homicide and manslaughter, but they could not establish the culpable negligence needed for that. Using the surveillance video that captured the fatal accident, investigators re-enacted the scene; considering that information, they decided the SUV was not backing quickly enough to prove Suarez-Contreras was driving recklessly when he drove over Murphy.

At the scene, the car's passenger, Luis Sanabria, gave sworn testimony to a law enforcement officer that Suarez-Contreras was operating the vehicle at the time of the crash. Sanabria was found to have an expired visa, according to the incident report, and was released into the custody of US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), Jacob Navarro, public affairs specialist for the Bay County Sheriff's Office, told Fox News Digital.

In considering charges, prosecutors also looked to a Florida law passed in 2023 that invalidates driver's licenses issued to illegal immigrants in certain states such as California, Connecticut and Delaware. Unfortunately, Basford said, the legislation does not designate Georgia as one of those states.

Murphy's family is devastated that there is no chance of justice, Edge said. She said they feel incredibly let down by the state of Florida, which vowed to seek justice on her mother's behalf, and that it is like experiencing the loss all over again. Edge said her mother was in great health and presumably had many more years with the family; now she will not attend her grandchildren's weddings or meet any more of her great-grandchildren, and that has been taken away.

The two sisters question the way their mother's death was investigated and why so much weight was given to a re-enactment of the incident. Edge said they know the man killed her, that he never got out of the car, never ran to her aid and never stopped. The family also questions why Suarez-Contreras was not tested for drugs or alcohol and why his phone records were not reviewed, while Murphy's body was subjected to a toxicology evaluation, her daughters said.

The sisters say they will continue to fight to bring positive changes from the tragedy; they may pursue changes to Florida law or to the way law enforcement officers conduct similar investigations. Edge said they will keep exploring their questions not in a vengeful way, but so that this does not happen to someone else. There is some comfort, she said, in knowing Suarez-Contreras is in ICE custody awaiting deportation, and their drive now is to ensure he is deported.

Suarez-Contreras's defense attorney, Russell Ramey, told Fox News Digital he is pleased the charges were dropped. After the case was dropped, Suarez-Contreras was transferred into ICE custody on 15 November, according to the Bay County Jail. Fox News Digital could not reach him for comment.

Get the news firstNew stories in your inbox — subscribe free.

More in America