…বাংলা
Barlekha Today logo
All the big stories — in your language, updated every 15 minutes
Home › America › News
America

Supreme Court Declines California Implicit-Bias Training Case as Justice Thomas Warns of Citizens Turned Into Government Mouthpieces

Staff Reporter
Supreme Court Declines California Implicit-Bias Training Case as Justice Thomas Warns of Citizens Turned Into Government Mouthpieces
Photo: Collected

The US Supreme Court on Monday declined to hear a challenge to a California law requiring instruction on implicit bias in mandatory training courses for licensed physicians. Justice Clarence Thomas dissented from the decision, joined by Justice Samuel Alito, arguing that allowing the law to stand could have implications reaching far beyond the medical field.

California requires all its licensed physicians to complete 50 hours of state-approved continuing education courses every two years. The courses must include instruction on implicit bias, either through examples of how it affects physicians' treatment decisions and health outcomes or through strategies for addressing how those biases may contribute to healthcare disparities.

Dr. Azadeh Khatibi, who teaches a continuing education course in California, sued the state alongside the right-of-center nonprofit Do No Harm. They argue, as Thomas did, that the requirement compels private instructors to convey a government-favored message in violation of the First Amendment.

Her legal team wrote that Khatibi does not want to include discussion of implicit bias in her courses, that it is not relevant to her topics, and that it would eat away at the limited time she could use to discuss relevant topics. She also disagrees that implicit bias is the primary factor driving disparities in healthcare.

California countered that while instructors must include discussion of implicit bias, they are not required to personally endorse the theory and may openly disagree with it. Instructors are also free to inform attendees that any discussion of implicit bias is included solely to comply with state requirements. The state further argued that states must be given broad authority to determine what doctors must do to retain their licenses.

The Ninth Circuit ruled last year that continuing medical education courses constitute government speech because of California's extensive regulation of the medical profession, meaning the state's requirements are not subject to First Amendment free-speech scrutiny.

‘When, as here, the government does not issue its own messages but instead requires private speakers to communicate the government's viewpoint, the First Amendment applies,’ Thomas wrote. ‘A State cannot regulate its way out of First Amendment scrutiny. We should not permit the government-speech doctrine to be wielded as a cover for censorship or a cloak for compelled speech.’

Thomas argued that California's requirement leaves the petitioners no choice but to discuss the topic in a way that affirms the state's view that implicit bias causes ‘disparities in health outcomes.’

He went on to argue that the ruling could reach Americans in many licensed professions, asking whether California could require a keynote speaker at a statewide legal conference to oppose racial preferences in law firm hiring. Under the Ninth Circuit's logic, he wrote, enough government regulation of a field would convert a private speaker's message into government speech unprotected by the First Amendment.

Justice Neil Gorsuch also dissented from the decision not to hear the case, though he did not sign on to the argument by Alito and Thomas. His rationale for wanting to grant review is not publicly known.

The Supreme Court's decision leaves the Ninth Circuit's ruling intact but does not settle whether California's requirement violates the First Amendment.

A spokesperson for Do No Harm said medical professionals should not be compelled by the government to participate in evidence-free implicit bias trainings. The group said it was disappointed the court declined the case but encouraged that some justices acknowledged the importance of the First Amendment issues at stake, and that it would keep fighting for constitutionally protected free speech.

Get the news firstNew stories in your inbox — subscribe free.

More in America