…বাংলা
Barlekha Today logo
All the big stories — in your language, updated every 15 minutes
Home › America › News
America

Epstein’s Death May Have Been Homicide, Forensic Expert Claims from Autopsy Evidence

Staff Reporter
Epstein’s Death May Have Been Homicide, Forensic Expert Claims from Autopsy Evidence
Photo: Collected

Senior forensic medicine expert Dr Michael Freeman has claimed that US sex offender Jeffrey Epstein’s death may not have been suicide but homicide. Epstein died in a New York jail in August 2019, when US authorities declared the death a suicide. But after analysing autopsy records and photographs, Freeman says the injury marks found on Epstein’s body strengthen the possibility of homicide. The New York Times reported the information on Monday.

Freeman, a researcher specialising in the forensic analysis of death and homicide, was given permission to review the full autopsy file on Epstein. Examining the records and photographs, he questioned the conclusion of the original investigation. A separate CBS report said Freeman identified marks on Epstein’s neck in the autopsy photographs that, in his view, are not usually seen in death by hanging.

According to Freeman’s observations, there were also injury marks on Epstein’s shoulders and back, which could indicate a physical struggle. As a possible explanation for the evidence, he said Epstein may have been strangled from behind with a cloth wrapped around his neck.

Freeman said an unusual mark on Epstein’s neck caught his attention the first time he examined the autopsy photographs. In a hanging suicide, he said, there is usually a smooth, diagonal mark on the neck that rises towards the knot of the ligature. But the mark on Epstein’s neck was deep and uneven, and on one side it split into two parts like the letter “Y”. Freeman said that on seeing the mark he thought, “Wait, this does not look like a hanging mark.” The unusual mark was one of the main reasons he questioned the original investigation’s conclusion.

Epstein’s younger brother, Mark Epstein, gave Freeman the full autopsy records last November, and Freeman analysed them for about a year. Cognitive neuroscientist Itiel Dror and Swedish forensic pathologist Anders Eriksson are working with him on the research. Freeman is trying to publish his findings in a peer-reviewed scientific journal, but his research has so far been rejected for publication.

Other forensic experts who examined some of Epstein’s autopsy photographs have also described the neck mark as unusual for a hanging suicide. But some of them cautioned that the unusual feature does not completely rule out suicide, and that the true circumstances of a death cannot be determined from body injury marks alone.

Meanwhile, the statement of a prison worker who first saw Epstein’s body has also come back into discussion. The worker initially refused to speak to investigators and gave his account for the first time two years after Epstein’s death. He claimed that when the body was recovered, the back of Epstein’s body was about 2.5 centimetres above the floor. Taking the worker’s account, the autopsy photographs and Epstein’s physical build into consideration, Freeman built a computer-generated three-dimensional (3D) simulation of death by hanging to test whether the evidence was consistent with the authorities’ determined circumstances of death.

However, Christine Roman, the pathologist who conducted Epstein’s original autopsy, told federal investigators she had no doubt Epstein died by suicide. According to Roman, Epstein’s body was in a normal state; no injury marks or dirt under the nails were found, and no signs of a struggle could be identified. In response, Freeman criticised investigators, saying no DNA test was done under Epstein’s nails. He also said Roman was not given permission to inspect the cell where the body was found, so her opportunity to examine the circumstances of the death on site was limited.

The publication of Freeman’s research has also sparked controversy in the United Kingdom. He was scheduled to present his findings at University College London (UCL). But on Sunday the university authorities abruptly announced that, considering student welfare, the event would not be held on campus. The event was then moved to Middle Temple, a London legal institution. Shortly before it began, Epstein’s brother Mark Epstein published the autopsy photographs online, making images previously seen by only a limited number of people available to the general public.

But while Freeman’s research raises the possibility of homicide, it is not conclusive proof that Epstein was murdered. US authorities still stand by their official conclusion that Epstein died by suicide. New York’s medical examiner’s office has also said it stands by the original autopsy’s conclusion.

Get the news firstNew stories in your inbox — subscribe free.

More in America