Using law to silence abuse victims is 'ultimate form of gaslighting', British MPs told
Attempts to silence victims of sexual abuse by using the law are the 'ultimate form of gaslighting', a survivor has told British members of parliament. She spoke at a hearing of the House of Commons justice committee on Tuesday.
Verity Nevitt is a co-founder of the Gemini Project, a survivor-led non-profit organisation. She told the committee that the man she and her sister Lucy accused of sexual abuse and rape had sued them. Lucy accused him of rape, and Verity accused him of sexual abuse.
The session was held after the conviction of Russell Brand for rape and sexual assault, and after allegations of improper behaviour against David Walliams, which he denies.
MPs heard that wealthy and powerful men silenced victims through injunctions, non-disclosure agreements and strategic lawsuits against public participation, known as Slapps. Slapps are used to harass or intimidate opponents who speak out on matters of public interest.
Nevitt said that when a person experiences rape or sexual assault, choice is taken from them. Being subject to a Slapp replicates those dynamics, because the person has no choice but to be subject to it.
She said Slapps allow a flipping of the script, in which the perpetrator is presented as a victim of wrongdoing, and the victim survivor is presented as the aggressor by being made a defendant. It is an egregious reversal of reality, and the ultimate form of gaslighting, she said.
Nevitt and her sister reported the man to the police. When the case was dropped, they decided to name him on social media to warn others. That led to him suing them.
They eventually reached an out-of-court agreement. Having waived their right to anonymity, the sisters could talk about the case without naming him.
Nevitt told MPs that in the case brought against her and her sister, the truth did not matter at all; it was all about the costs. She said that after the first hearing, the solicitor took the sisters aside and told them they would have to find 100,000 pounds to make it to the next hearing.
Jennifer Robinson, a barrister and co-author of Silenced Women: Why The Law Fails Women and How to Fight Back, told MPs that survivors who were sued faced huge costs. She said the chilling effect was not limited to women who wanted to speak out.
Robinson said it was also having a chilling effect on journalists' willingness, and their newspapers' willingness, to report these stories, which was not in the public interest. She said: 'We can't tackle violence against women if we can't talk about it.'
Harriet Wistrich, the chief executive of the Centre for Women's Justice, said there was a good argument for 'very severe cost capping' in such cases.
Rupert Cowper-Coles, a partner and head of media at RPC solicitors, told the committee the UK was a 'major outlier amongst western democracies' because it did not have a general anti-Slapp law, but one that only covered disclosures relating to economic crime.
Robinson asked why the protection of public interest speech on economic crimes was being privileged, and not speech about crimes against women, in the context of the crisis of violence against women in society.




