Biden explains 'we beat Medicare' moment in new memoir

Former President Joe Biden has reflected in his new memoir, 'Promise Me, America', on his 'we beat Medicare' moment from the June 2024 debate. In the book, released on Tuesday, he lamented that the moment had become 'Exhibit A' that he was too old to do the job.
Biden wrote that, as he was finishing an answer on the deficit, he lost his train of thought, saw that his time was running out on the clock, and rushed the final part of his answer by blurting out: 'We finally beat Medicare.' He wrote that what he meant to say was, 'We finally beat Big Pharma.'
He wrote that this had been a huge accomplishment in his administration. As part of the Inflation Reduction Act, his administration had secured for Medicare the power to negotiate for lower drug prices.
Biden wrote that, ironically, this historic achievement would not lift his candidacy; it would help to sink it. What should have been a highlight of the debate became Exhibit A that he was too old to do the job, he wrote.
Biden accused President Donald Trump of repeatedly lying during the debate, writing that none of what Trump said generated any impression that lasted past debate night. It was his own answers and performance that dominated press coverage and political conversation in the weeks ahead, he wrote.
Biden wrote that he knew the debate had gone badly, but that debates had gone badly for lots of incumbent presidents, especially their first ones. He left the stage thinking he would be debating Trump once more before the election was over, he wrote.
He wrote that pundits and Democratic leaders decided the performance was 'fatal', but polling immediately after the debate showed the gap between him and Trump shrinking. It would take weeks of hammering in the press before the polls started to move downward, he wrote.
By comparison, he wrote, in the days after losing his first debate with Mitt Romney, Barack Obama had lost five points in the horse race. But the data was not the point, Biden wrote; the narrative was, and the narrative was bad — there was a consensus that he had lost, and worse, a consensus that it could not be fixed.
Biden wrote that other incumbent presidents had also performed poorly in debates but later recovered. During the 2012 election cycle, his own debate against Romney's running mate, Paul Ryan, took on a 'special urgency' after Obama's 'terrible' debate against the Republican nominee, he wrote.
What happened to Obama was not unique, Biden wrote. Ronald Reagan looked lost and confused against Walter Mondale, George W. Bush was caught with a scowling face, and Obama looked like he did not care if he won or lost. Biden wrote that incumbent presidents often have bad first debates because they are more focused on the country's and the world's problems than on campaigning.
Biden wrote that the difference in 2024 was not that he had a bad debate — lots of presidents had bad debates — but that every other president was given the chance to redeem themselves in a second debate, and that chance would not be available to him.
In an interview about his memoir, Biden told People magazine he considered his debate performance inconsequential. He said he did not know anybody who had not made a mistake in a debate, that to him it was not very consequential, and that he thought there would be another debate, which there was not.
Biden wrote that the debate 'didn't feel right from the start'. The debate ultimately preceded his decision to exit the race after weeks of pressure from fellow Democrats.
Former first lady Jill Biden said during a CBS News 'Sunday Morning' interview in May that she thought her husband was having a stroke on stage during the debate.
Costas Panagopoulos, a professor of political science at Northeastern University, told Fox News Digital that Biden is correct that he was not the only president to have a bad debate performance and that previous candidates had an opportunity to recover. The problem for Biden, he said, was not simply a bad debate but that his poor performance reinforced a prevalent narrative that he was ill-equipped to run the country given his advanced age, and the debate put the final nail in the coffin.




