…বাংলা
Barlekha Today logo
All the big stories — in your language, updated every 15 minutes
Home › Entertainment › News
Entertainment

Ten Controversies Behind the Crown: 74 Years of Miss Universe Scandals

Staff Reporter
Ten Controversies Behind the Crown: 74 Years of Miss Universe Scandals
Photo: Collected

The 75th edition of Miss Universe is under way in San Juan, Puerto Rico, with the final scheduled for November 24 and contestants from more than a hundred countries taking part. But the pageant, which began in 1952, carries more than seven decades of controversies behind the crown, from accusations of bias against judges to a wrong winner being announced on live television.

One of the earliest major controversies came in 1957. After Mary Leona Gage of the United States was crowned Miss USA, it emerged that she was married with two children and had also given false information about her age. Under the rules of the time, married women and mothers could not compete, so her crown was taken away and the first runner-up became the new Miss USA.

In 1996, Venezuela's Alicia Machado won the Miss Universe crown at just 19. Machado alleged that, after she gained some weight, pageant owner Donald Trump repeatedly humiliated her over her body, forced her to exercise in front of journalists and cameras, and mocked her as 'Miss Piggy' and 'Miss Housekeeping'. The episode returned to prominence during the 2016 US presidential campaign, when Hillary Clinton raised Machado's case in an election debate to criticise Trump's behaviour.

In 2002, Oxana Fedorova became the first Russian contestant to win the crown, but she lost it just 119 days later. The organisation said she was removed for failing to fulfil her duties; Fedorova said she had resigned of her own accord. The first runner-up, Justine Pasek of Panama, was ultimately declared Miss Universe.

The closing moment of the 2015 pageant remains one of the most remembered controversies in its history. Host Steve Harvey mistakenly announced Colombia's Ariadna Gutiérrez as the winner, and she was crowned. Moments later Harvey returned to the stage to say he had made a mistake — the real winner was Pia Wurtzbach of the Philippines. The crown was taken from Gutiérrez and placed on Wurtzbach's head, and the scene, broadcast live around the world, went viral. Harvey accepted responsibility for the error.

In 2018, attention turned to the contestants' own behaviour. An Instagram Live video by Sarah Rose Summers of the United States, Valeria Morales of Colombia and Francesca Hung of Australia spread widely, in which they commented on the Cambodian and Vietnamese representatives' inability to speak English. Facing criticism, Summers later apologised.

In 2020, after Mexico's Andrea Meza won the crown, controversy erupted when photos of her in wedding attire circulated on social media, because the rules of the time required contestants to be unmarried. It later emerged that the photos were part of an advertisement shoot; the model in them, Jorge Saenz, said there was no marital relationship between them and that they were friends. In the end, Meza's crown was not affected.

In 2024, Miss USA 2023 Noelia Voigt abruptly announced she was giving up her crown, citing her mental health, and within days Miss Teen USA UmaSofia Srivastava also resigned. Voigt's mother alleged that after a misconduct complaint against a driver linked to the pageant was reported to the organisation, adequate support was not provided; the officials concerned denied the allegations.

After ownership passed to Thailand's JKN Global Group, married women, mothers and women over 28 became eligible to compete. But a video from 2023 sparked a fresh controversy, with the group's then chief Anne Jakrajutatip allegedly heard saying that contestants of diverse identities could take part but could not win. Anne said her remarks had been misrepresented and that the discussion had been about a reality show.

At the 2025 pageant in Thailand, organiser Nawat Itsaragrisil publicly rebuked Mexico's representative Fátima Bosch at an event for allegedly not taking part in promotional work; Bosch protested and walked out, joined by several other contestants. The Miss Universe organisation condemned Nawat's behaviour and he later apologised. Judge Omar Harfouch then resigned, alleging an unauthorised judging panel and a lack of transparency over the results, which the organisation denied. In the end, Fátima Bosch herself won the Miss Universe 2025 crown.

Controversy has followed this year's 75th edition as well. The Puerto Rican government had promised 8.7 million dollars to host the pageant and released 4.5 million dollars, but questions over the accounts and spending documents have led the country's Senate to open an inquiry, while the organisers have denied financial irregularities. Because of disputes over national franchise rights and licences, the representatives of six countries — Thailand, Vietnam, Indonesia, Malaysia, Singapore and Laos — are not taking part in this year's pageant.

Get the news firstNew stories in your inbox — subscribe free.

More in Entertainment